Re “The Little Lame Prince”

In an earlier post, I discussed (a little) the fact that Frank Godwin produced  “cover-labels” for several rather small books in David McKay’s series of books known as “McKay’s Young People’s Classics.” (The cover-labels are the paper labels pasted to the fronts of many books back in the “olden days.”) I believe that Godwin produced illustrations for eight or nine (or so) of the covers in that series.

This is apart from several larger books published by McKay that also had cover labels by Godwin.  These larger works included Robin Hood, The Black Arrow, and The Blue Fairy Book. A version of The Black Arrow published in England had a different cover-label by Godwin. The cover-labels of the books mentioned in this paragraph were based on illustrations also found inside the book. I have copies of all of these as well.

Of course, cover-labels by Godwin also appeared on still other books.  Offhand, I think all such others were published by Winston.

In my collection, I think I have eight or so different examples of “McKay’s Young People’s Classics” with Godwin covers.

In another post, I discussed the cover for The Arabian Nights, from the same series, which was quite lovely.  The one for The Little Lame Prince is simpler and not really as attractive as the one for The Arabian Nights and certain others in the series.  (Still pretty attractive though!)

connie-1-12-17-3-copy-2aa

Obviously the above is only a portion of the image–probably about half of the image, since I cropped off a lot of the top and bottom (but not all that much of the sides).

—Tom Sawyer

January 18, 2017

Advertisements
Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Happy New Year from “Connie,” 76 years ago–but not Frank Godwin’s Connie!

Below is shown the Connie bottom-strip for the Sunday episode for December 29, 1940. If you are somewhat familiar with Frank Godwin’s principal styles of Connie art, it is unlikely that you will think that this portrayal of Connie was actually drawn by Frank Godwin.

connie-1-12-17-2-copy-1-12-17

It is not at all badly drawn, but (for instance) the haziness of Connie’s far shoulder is very uncharacteristic of Godwin. And her hair is somewhat “off” from Godwin’s style.

In another segment of that Connie page, shown below, it is easily seen that the lettering is nothing like that of Godwin’s attractive style.  Likewise, it can be seen that the execution of the drawing is quite well done, and it even seems to have been executed in a Godwin-esque style of art, but it is different enough from Godwin’s typical work that one can say that Godwin did not draw it. I could not swear that Godwin did not do the pencils, but there is no real reason to suppose that he did. The foregoing comments also apply to the small portion of the story itself shown above.

connie-1-12-17-1-copy-1-12-17

The complex layout of the panels (or quasi-panels) is also rather Godwin-esque.

Additionally, as I noted in a different post, Godwin’s name does not appear in the logo (not completely shown above).

Nonetheless, the art is quite nice.   The clouds are very Godwin-like, as is the composition.  But Connie herself does not look much like a Godwin rendering, and the speech balloons are not Godwin-esque.

This line of dialog, spoken by Connie, seems quite strange to me: “WHILE YOU’RE AWAY I’LL GO LOOK AT THE BOATS–JUST FOR EXCITEMENT–TERRIFIC EXCITEMENT ISN’T IT?”

The use of the word “excitement” twice seems odd.

There are many ways that line of Connie’s could be improved.  Something like this might have worked better: “While you two are away, I’m going to take a look at those boats–they look exciting.” But even that seems weird, because, to make the subsequent adventure seem more interesting and unexpected, her real reason should be along the lines of “it’s something to do to kill the time,” or there might have been an indication that something was unusual and worth investigating.

In short: (a) art quite nice but very probably not Godwin; (b) lettering  (including spacing within the balloons) not that great; (c) dialog could probably have been better.

I discussed this episode in some detail in the post found at the following link: LINK.  Also, in the post found at this link: LINK.

–Tom Sawyer

January 12, 2017

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Comments on Connie’s “sort of” final Sunday story . . .

I don’t think anyone has set forth–or even has knowledge of–“when” the final Connie Sunday episode appeared. It is pretty certain that Frank Godwin left the Sunday Connie strip before the end of 1940. I imagine that he stopped work on the Sunday strip several weeks before the end of the year. But, of course, his final work on the strip would have been published a noticeable amount of time after he stopped, maybe six weeks or so.

Connie’s first Sunday science-fiction story had her travel 1,ooo years into the future, to the year 2936, due to the activity of a mischief-causing cat.

In the final “known” complete story, she travelled 100 or so years into the past (measuring from the newspaper date). In an earlier post (not viewable at the moment), I mentioned that she had gone to the year 1840, but I am not certain what I based that on.

Below is an image of a portion of the November 24, 1940, strip. The introduction kind of sets the scene. Notice that Jim Walker’s sister has the name Sylvia, which also was the name of Godwin’s second wife.

This time machine, a two-seater, looks completely different from the machine built by Dr. Chrono, whose machine had one seat only.

This strip definitely shows no signs of anyone’s work besides that of Frank Godwin. In other words, this strip (that is, the original art, probably not in existence now) was drawn and inked by Godwin.

The dynamic shapes of the panels  (as opposed to rectangular boxes) are reasonably typical of the layouts of many (but not all) of the Connie science-fiction and adventure pages. I doubt that any of the Connie “gag” (humor) strips used that sort of layout.

scan-12-19-16-1-copy-rotated-150ppi

The entire story consisted of strips for the following dates:

November 17, 1940

November 24, 1940

December 1, 1940

December 8, 1940

December 15, 1940

  December 22, 1940

I have in my collection the Connie strips for the dates shown in boldface. I have the Paulette strips for all six dates. Paulette was the title of the Connie strips as published in French in Canada. (The Paulette strips appeared after the Connie strips.)

I have not seen the ones in English for 11-17, 12-1, 12-8, or 12-15, but I see zero possibility that they don’t exist! Well, let me take that back. There is ALMOST zero possibility. The only secure way of showing they exist would be for someone to produce examples of them!

Regarding the last two episodes mentioned, it is pretty obvious to me that someone else besides Godwin inked the final one, and I think someone else at least partly inked the second-to-last strip. I discussed this at some length in another post.

Now there are a few other points to bear in mind when thinking about the final Connie stories and final episodes. The six strips mentioned above do constitute a story. But one could probably also disregard the first one, because (based on my Paulette example) the end of the 11-17 strip is basically a transition to the new story.

Then again, on the other hand, one might want to say that the five or six strips under discussion constitute a “sub-story” that is part of a longer narrative beginning some time before those strips.

The other wrinkle to all this is that the Sunday strip did continue after the December 22, 1940 strip. Exactly how many strips appeared, and whether they were published in papers other than the Boston Sunday Post, and whether any were in color, are questions that even now are shrouded in deep mystery. I do have examples of the strips for December 29, 1940, and January 5, 1941, in black and white, from the Boston Sunday Post. The relevant website of Ohio State University lists one for January 19, 1941.

—Tom Sawyer

December 30, 2016

Posted in Uncategorized | 2 Comments

76 Years Ago Today — December 22, 1940 — A Merry Christmas Wish from a “non-Frank Godwin” Connie — and from Tom!

Merry Christmas!

Below is an image of an extract from the December 22, 1940, Sunday episode of Connie.  Mainly shown is a large chunk of the “bottom strip,” which when present normally featured The Wet Blanket or Wonder-Land.

So, that was 76 years ago today! Weird, how long ago that was.

This is from the Boston Sunday Post, which normally ran the Connie Sunday strip (and bottom strip) in color, but not the last few episodes.

You can see the 12-22 date in the lower-left corner of the actual Connie strip.

In is quite certain that Godwin had little if anything to do with this particular episode (though he may have pencilled it). Even from the very bottom that I show here, it is obvious that the inking was of a “scribble” nature that is quite unlike Godwin’s inking.

It is also obvious that the picture of Connie in the bottom strip was not drawn by Godwin. Her hair is rendered rather crudely, and the shading is very non-Godwin.  A “Connie” logo does appear after the “Merry Christmas.”

12-22-40-bos-sun-post

This was the final episode of this story, but there were at least two Connie Sundays that appeared after this. (The daily continued well into 1941. As I recall, this is shown by the strips cataloged on the Ohio State University comic-strip website.)

—Tom Sawyer

December 22, 2016

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Frank Godwin and “Uncle Henry” . . .

Happy Thanksgiving to all!

One of the features of Collier’s during a period of many years was the series of “Uncle Henry” articles. I don’t know whether the authorship of the articles has ever been established, although Irvin S. Cobb wrote an introduction to a book which included a number of the pieces.

Following is a somewhat cropped image of the front cover of the June 10, 1922, issue of Colliers. The basic image by Frank Godwin of Uncle Henry (with variations) was used in a number of contexts. For instance, it appeared on the dust jacket of at least version of the book mentioned above, and also on the actual cover (stamped in black), and also as the frontispiece.

img_0893

—Tom Sawyer

November 24, 2016

Posted in Uncategorized | 2 Comments

Comments on the Frank Godwin aviation print pictured on Liz Rizzo’s “Frank Godwin, Artist” Facebook page . . .

On November 1, 2016, Liz Rizzo posted (on her Facebook page) a few images of a Frank Godwin aviation print submitted by a reader. Basically, it is a World War I aviation scene.

I thought I would post a few comments here. It might provide added reason for people to visit this blog!

I have an example of the print in my collection, and it has white margins. I purchased it on eBay many years ago. I think I have seen two or so other examples on eBay over the years.

The print was issued by Collier’s magazine back in 1928.

Originally, the image was used as an illustration for a short-story by Laurie York Erskine, entitled “Pryde’s Fall.” The story appeared in the July 21, 1928, issue of Collier’s. (According to Wikipedia, Erskine served in France in the Royal Flying Corps starting in 1916.)

At the end of the story was a note stating that the print would be sent “on receipt of 4 cents in stamps.”

The illustration appeared on pages 26 and 27 of that issue.  The story started on page  24, and it included one other Godwin illustration as well.

The first illustration shows Captain Pryde (on the left) with an officer who was transferring out of Pryde’s unit. Pryde was a “go getter,” but since the war was near its end, some people just wanted to chill till the war was over.

img_0874

The color illustration shows Pryde’s airplane on the ground.  He climbed out of it,. and then a German plane appeared to be attacking him. He fell to the ground (dodging bullets). The German plane (red, at the right) crashed.

img_0869

People thought Pryde was dead, and after that they went all “gung ho” (instead of just waiting for the war to end).

The war ended shortly after, with everyone being thrilled when the learned that Pryde had survived.

The following shows part of both versions.  The “print” is on the right–you can see the margins.  Notice that the coloration is somewhat different from that of the magazine version. I suppose that one could say the print is a bit more nuanced.

img_0864

—Tom Sawyer

November 16, 2016

Posted in Uncategorized | 4 Comments

Re-posting: Brief comments on the first Sunday “Connie” science-fiction story (a 31-episode time-travel story, in which Connie, Dr. Chrono, and Jack travel to the thirtieth century), and a correlation of its appearance in the United States with its appearance (in “Paulette”) in Canada during 1936 and 1937 . . .

Note (11-14-16): Recently I purchased two 1936 Connie Sunday strips on eBay, as well as one strip from late in 1940.  I was especially glad to get the 1940 strip, which was was from quite late in the year, and was (as far as I can tell) not the final Sunday Connie, but almost so. In reviewing some other material, I noted that the first Sunday science-fiction Connie was the one for August 2, 1936. So the 80th anniversary of that strip passed not long ago.

I don’t think that the key August 2, 1936, strip is one of the rarest Connie Sundays. If you set out to find one, you might never be able to do that, but on the other hand, I think I may have three examples of that in my collection: one black-and-white full, one full-color full, and one full-color tabloid. I hope to check on that within the next few days, but if you collect Sunday pages from that era, you are probably aware that they can be quite cumbersome, and difficult to refer to.

Anyway, below is a post that related to the science-fiction story under discussion. I originally posted it in 2012, and then I took it down in January 2013, so I presume that some of you never saw it, and that most or all of the rest of you have little recollection of it.

Elsewhere in this blog, I have touched upon the relationship between Connie in the United States and Paulette in Canada.  La Presse ran Paulette on Saturdays.  It was a translation of Connie, and it generally appeared somewhat later than Connie. (I do not know whether Paulette appeared anywhere other than in La Presse.  It seems as though it would have.)

The first Connie Sunday science-fiction story started generally in the United States on Sunday, August 2, 1936.  In that episode, Connie and Jack visit Dr. Chrono, and he starts to demonstrate his “time traveler.” That first episode must have been a bit of a surprise to readers, because for (at least) months before that the Sunday strip had been mainly (maybe solely) a gag strip, and as far as I know the vast majority of Connie Sunday episodes, for years, were gag strips.  There were some detective-style strips, and at least a couple of gags where Connie was a reporter, and maybe there were some non-gag Sunday strips that I am not familiar with.  But overall, it seems that the Sunday Connie was a gag strip until that momentous date of August 2, 1936, which changed forever the direction of the Connie Sunday strip.

That same episode appeared in La Presse on August 29, 1936.  So, right there, that Paulette episode appeared close to four weeks later in Canada (at least in La Presse) than it did in the US.

The second Connie Sunday science-fiction episode appeared on August 9, 1936.  In that episode, Connie is transported one thousand years into her future, to the year 2936.

But in Canada, that episode appeared on September 26, 1936, creating an additional three-week separation — there was then a seven-week gap between the US and Canada appearances!

Below is an attempt at a further correlation.  This is based almost entirely on my Paulette comic strips, which, in all but a few cases, bear both the (Saturday) date of the paper (not as part of the strip proper), and the (Sunday) date on the strip.  Where I have placed a date in brackets, it means that I didn’t find the date on the strip itself.  The dates on the strips themselves are usually two numbers separated by a hyphen, showing first the month, and then the day, such as “9-6” for September 6.

I’ve already discussed the first two episodes (above). Below are listed the other 29 episodes.  Episode numbers below were created by me:

Episode 3

Connie, in her twentieth-century garb, talks with the people of the future.  The final frame has a “UN” logo.

US:  August 16, 1936

Canada:  October 3, 1936

Episode 4:

Connie is still in twentieth-century dress.  The fourth panel shows a flying vehicle, and the sixth panel shows a reclining Connie.

US:  August 23, 1936

Canada:  October 10, 1936

Episode 5:

In the first frame, Connie is wearing twentieth-century clothes.  In the second frame, she is wearing thirtieth-century clothes.

US: August 30, 1936

Canada: October 24, 1936 (At the time there was an eight-week gap.)

Episode 6:

Jack and Dr. Chrono are in panels six, seven, and eight.

US:  September 6, 1936

Canada:  October 31, 1936

Episode 7:

Jack and Dr. Chrono arrive in the thirtieth century and are shown in the last panel.

US:  September 13, 1936

Canada:  November 7, 1936

Episode 8:

The top row is one panel, and it shows Connie, Dr. Chrono, Jack, and others.

US:  September 20, 1936

Canada: November 14, 1936

Episode 9:

The top row is one panel, showing Connie, Jack, and Dr. Chrono in their futuristic garb.

US:  September 27, 1936

Canada:  November 28, 1936 (At the time there was an additional delay of a week.)

Episode 10

First appearance of the spaceship called “Meteor.”

US:  October 4, 1936  (The strip is dated “10-4,” so it corresponds with the date given.  As I indicated, most of the actual strips are dated.)

Canada:  December 19, 1936  (We might have expected it to appear on December 5, so there is yet another delay, this one of two weeks.)

Episode 11:

The third panel shows the moon in the distance.

US: October 11, 1936

Canada:  December 26, 1936

All right, for the remaining episodes, I am going to be more succinct.  I will state the episode number, and the US date, and, in parentheses, the Canada date.

12: October 18, 1936 (January 2, 1937)

13:  October 24, 1936 (January 9, 1937)

14:  October 31, 1936 (January 16, 1937)

15:  November 1, 1936 (January 23, 1937)

16: November 8, 1936 (January 30, 1937)

17:  November 22, 1936 (February 6, 1937)

Episode 18 would have been published in the United States on November 29, 1936, and in Canada on February 13, 1937. I did not locate the relevant Paulette when preparing the list.

19: December 6, 1936 (February 20, 1937)

20:  December 13, 1936 (February 27, 1937)

21:  December 20, 1936 (March 6, 1937)

Episode 22 would have been published in the United States on December 27, 1936, and in Canada on March 13, or March 20, or March 27, 1937.  I either don’t have that episode of Paulette, or, more likely, I just don’t have it readily available.

23: January 3, 1937 (April 3, 1937)

24:  January 10, 1937 (April 10, 1937)

25:  January 17, 1937 (April 17, 1937)

26: [January 24, 1937] (April 24, 1937)

27:  January 31, 1937 (May 1, 1937)

28:  [February 7, 1937] (May 22, 1937)

29:  February 14, 1937 (May 29, 1937)

30:  February 21, 1937 (June 5, 1937)

31:  February 28, 1937 (June 12, 1937)

And that (February 28, 1937) was the final episode for that time-travel story.  A new story started in the US on March 7, 1937.

By the time the story ended, the Canada version was about fifteen weeks later than the US version!

The science-fiction story discussed in this post is extremely important to the whole Connie series.  As far as I know, the Connie Sunday strip never included any gags after that story started.  The story’s art, including the settings, compositions, attire, figures, colors, and everything else about it, is handled beautifully.

—Tom Sawyer

March 24, 2012

Slightly revised on March 26, 2012

Posted in Making Private January 28, 2013, Uncategorized | Leave a comment